New curated entry: Visit the Economy & Progress Hub for a guided pathway through this project’s paper, executive summary, audio, video, visual materials, and related Commons pathways.
Audiobook on ElevenReader (Listen)
Download Full Document (PDF)
Life-Coherent Progress (PPT) (PDF)
The Life Coherent Economy (PPT) (PDF)
Explainer | An Economy Answerable to Life
Cinematic | The Measurement Paradox: Why “Beyond GDP” is Failing
Deep Diver | An economy answerable to life (Transcript)
Debate | Making the Global Economy Answerable to Life
Critique | Life Coherent Economics for Small Island States
Click on infographic to enlarge
Master Diagram
Executive Summary
The global movement beyond GDP marks a significant opening in the redefinition of progress. Gross domestic product remains useful as a narrow measure of monetized economic activity, but it cannot tell whether people are well, whether life-necessities are secure, whether ecological systems are being regenerated or destroyed, whether inequalities are widening, or whether current prosperity is being purchased at the expense of other peoples, species, ecosystems, and future generations. The United Nations Beyond GDP agenda therefore creates an important new compass by calling for multidimensional measures of well-being, equity, sustainability, resilience, and future viability.
Yet a new compass is not enough if the vessel remains powered by the same engine. This white paper argues that the deeper crisis is not only one of mismeasurement, but of misorganization. The dominant economy does not merely count the wrong things; it organizes production, finance, trade, technology, and governance around accumulation rather than life-capacity, ecological integrity, democratic provisioning, and repair. Jason Hickel’s political economy clarifies this missing layer. His analysis shows that ecological overshoot and human deprivation coexist not because the world lacks productive capacity, but because productive capacity is misallocated: destructive excess is overprovided while life-necessities remain underproduced.
This paper develops a life-coherent synthesis of the Beyond GDP agenda and Hickel’s critique. It interprets Hickel’s work alongside John McMurtry’s life-value onto-axiology, Johan Galtung’s theory of structural violence, and Humberto Maturana and Francisco Varela’s account of living systems, autopoiesis, and world-bringing. Together, these perspectives make it possible to understand the present crisis as a civilizational inversion: money-value has become sovereign over life-value; avoidable deprivation has been normalized within social structures; ecological overshoot has been externalized; and whole worlds of policy, economy, and development have been brought forth through distinctions that make accumulation appear natural and life-necessity secondary.
The life-coherent framework proposed here reframes progress as the democratic organization of the life-means. Progress is not simply more output, faster growth, or higher national income. It is the secure and equitable provisioning of the material, social, ecological, and institutional conditions through which persons and communities can live, develop, participate, care, learn, create, deliberate, belong, and flourish. Decent living standards define a minimum life-capacity floor. Planetary boundaries define a life-supporting ceiling. A life-coherent economy must operate within this corridor: enough for all, within the conditions that allow life to continue.
This paper also extends the Beyond GDP agenda by emphasizing cross-border life-drain. National progress cannot be judged only by domestic indicators. A country may appear prosperous while relying on labour, land, materials, energy, ecological space, and financial flows appropriated from elsewhere. Hickel’s work on unequal exchange reveals how prosperity in the global North is often sustained through structural transfers from the global South, while debt, ecological burden, climate vulnerability, and constrained sovereignty flow back in return. A life-coherent dashboard must therefore include relational accountability: no society can be considered genuinely progressing if its well-being depends on the deprivation or ecological destabilization of others.
The paper further argues that degrowth is best understood not as universal austerity, but as differentiated life-coherent convergence. High-consuming economies must downscale destructive and unnecessary throughput, while materially deprived societies must expand life-necessary provisioning. The task is not to choose between growth and degrowth in the abstract, but to ask what must grow, what must shrink, what must be shared, what must be repaired, and what must be protected.
The proposed life-coherent progress dashboard includes seven domains: life-necessity sufficiency, life-capacity development, life-ground integrity, distribution and inclusion, democratic control of life-means, cross-border life-drain, and repair and future viability. These domains are intended not merely as indicators, but as guides for institutional redesign, public investment, planning, budgeting, trade policy, ecological repair, and democratic accountability.
Small island developing states, and the Caribbean in particular, provide a powerful diagnostic lens for this framework. In SIDS, climate vulnerability, food dependence, debt exposure, water insecurity, fossil-fuel dependence, coastal degradation, public health strain, and constrained sovereignty are visibly interlinked. These societies reveal why GDP-centred measures are insufficient and why progress must be judged by life-ground security, provisioning resilience, regional cooperation, and meaningful sovereignty.
The central conclusion is that an economy becomes legitimate only insofar as it serves life-capacity, protects the life-ground, repairs life-damage, and remains democratically answerable to the communities and ecosystems through which life continues. The task is therefore not simply to move beyond GDP. It is to bring forth an economy answerable to life.
The Life-Coherent Progress Dashboard Domains and Measures
Please scroll to the right to see the right columns if on a mobile device| Domain | Indicative Measures | Policy Implications | Core Objective | Primary Scholars (Inferred) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life-necessity sufficiency | Food, water, sanitation, housing, health, education, energy, transport, care | Public provisioning, universal basic services, social guarantees | Universal access to the material conditions of dignified life. | Doyal, Gough, Hickel, Sullivan |
| Life-capacity development | Health, learning, participation, dignity, belonging, creativity | Prevention, education, culture, democratic participation | The ability of persons and communities to live, develop, participate, care, learn, create, deliberate, belong, and flourish. | McMurtry, Maturana, Varela |
| Life-ground integrity | Carbon, materials, land, biodiversity, water, pollution, coastal health | Ecological limits, restoration, circular systems, conservation | Regenerative relationships within planetary boundaries to sustain all life. | Rockström, Raworth, Richardson |
| Distribution and inclusion | Income, wealth, land, housing, energy, public services | Redistribution, labour rights, taxation, social protection | Fair distribution of life-means and opportunities between and within countries. | Hickel, Slameršak, Raworth |
| Democratic control of life-means | Public, cooperative, commons, community governance | Participatory budgeting, public ownership, cooperative models | Equitable access to goods and services via institutions accountable to life-need rather than accumulation. | Hickel, McMurtry |
| Cross-border life-drain | Embodied labour, materials, land, carbon, debt, profit repatriation | Trade justice, debt justice, supply-chain accountability | Relational accountability for externalized harms and extractive dependencies. | Hickel, Hanbury Lemos, Barbour |
| Repair and future viability | Adaptation, resilience, restoration, debt relief, future safeguards | Reparations, climate finance, long-term public investment | Intergenerational stewardship, restoration of damage, and safeguarding future generations. | Hickel, Fanning, Galtung |
One thought on “An Economy Answerable to Life: Beyond GDP, Unequal Exchange, and the Life-Coherent Reordering of Progress | ChatGPT-5.5 Thinking and NoteboolLM”